How To Tell The Difference Between Natural And Synthetic Supplements
I’m the first to admit that taking supplements is a pain in the ass. It can be expensive, it’s a bit of an inconvenience, and I would much prefer to receive all of the nutrients I need from food. However, the reality is that our food these days just doesn’t cut it – even if you eat a clean, organic diet. We need supplements to make up for the areas our bodies are lacking in.
“We need these additional nutrients because our soils, our farming techniques, our food processing and our food distribution system result in nutrient depleted foods,” says awesome integrative doctor Dr Mark Hyman. “Even with the perfect diet, the combination of our depleted soils, the storage and transportation of our foods around the world, the genetic alterations of traditional heirloom species, and the increased stress and nutritional demand resulting from a toxic environment make it almost impossible for us to get the vitamins and minerals we need just from the foods we eat. The evidence shows that we can’t get away from the need for nutritional supplements.”
Everyone’s supplement needs are different, so I highly recommend being tested by a naturopath or an integrative doctor to find out what your body needs. I did a Smart DNA test with Dr Sherill Sellman to discover what my body is asking for.
Another reason I recommend working with an expert on your supplement plan is so they can prescribe the best quality vitamins and minerals. Purchasing them from any old pharmacy or health food store won’t guarantee that you’ll be consuming something of quality. In fact, more often than not, store-bought supplements are made up of mostly synthetic ingredients, which can do more harm than good.
Our bodies are not designed to consume synthetics. It confuses them. Instead of nourishing us, synthetic ingredients rob us of nutrients because our bodies mine minerals from their own reserves to make up for what’s missing in the pill or food or whatever we’ve consumed. Our bodies know what to do with ingredients that are whole and genuinely natural and they will take as much as they need while excreting the rest. When the ingredient is synthetic, the excess is stored in our cells and fatty tissues and leads to toxicity.
JUST BECAUSE IT SAYS ‘NATURAL’ DOESN’T MEAN IT IS
In a similar form of sorcery to the beauty industry, vitamins can be labelled as natural if they contain as little as 10% of the natural form of the vitamin. So, that “natural” vitamin you’re consuming may actually be made up of 90% synthetic chemicals. The Organic Consumers Organization recommends looking for products that contain “100 percent plant-based” or “100 percent animal-based” on the product’s label.
WHAT TO LOOK FOR ON THE LABEL
1. The food source: A food source will indicate that the product has been made from something natural. A missing food source indicates it was made in a test tube. Look for food sources such as yeast, fish, vegetable and citrus. Also, identify whole foods in the ingredient list instead of the particular nutrient.
2. Salt forms: Salt forms (like acetate, bitartrate, chloride, gluconate, hydrochloride, nitrate and succinate) are synthetic ingredients added to supplements to increase the stability of the vitamin or mineral.
3. These keywords: Words that end in “ide” or “ate” (like chloride, hydrochloride, acetate or nitrate) indicate that the product contains salt forms, which are synthetics. If you see the letters “dl” before the name of an ingredients, this tells you it’s synthetic.
COMMON SYNTHETIC VITAMINS TO AVOID
Look for clues on your vitamin’s label that offer insight into the origin of the vitamin.
Vitamin A: Acetate and Palmitate
Vitamin B1 (Thiamine): Thiamine Mononitrate, Thiamine Hydrochloride
Vitamin B2 (Riboflavin): Riboflavin
Pantothenic Acid: Calcium D-Pantothenate
Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxine): Pyridoxine Hydrochloride
Vitamin B12: Cobalamin
PABA (Para-aminobenzoic Acid): Aminobenzoic Acid
Folic Acid: Pteroylglutamic Acid
Choline: Choline Chloride, Choline Bitartrate
Biotin: d-Biotin
Vitamin C (Ascorbic Acid): Ascorbic Acid
Vitamin D: Irradiated Ergosteral, Calciferol
Vitamin E: dl-alpha tocopherol, dl-alpha tocopherol acetate or succinate
NOTE: The “dl” form of any vitamin is synthetic.
Other Toxic Ingredients to Avoid In Supplements
• Magnesium stearate (or stearic acid)
• Monosodium Glutamate (MSG) disguised as “natural flavors”
• Carnauba wax is used in car wax and shoe polish
• Titanium dioxide is a carcinogen
(The above list was taken from: http://www.globalhealingcenter.com/natural-health/synthetic-vs-natural-vitamins/)
Again, I highly recommend seeing a naturopath or integrative doctor to work out the best supplement plan for you. This is the best way to not only make sure you’re only taking what you need, but they will be able to prescribe reputable brands. Still, grill them about the ingredients and make it very clear that you will only consume something if it’s 100% natural and 0% synthetic.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on the supplement topic. Which do you take? Do you see an expert or to do just take what you feel you need? Share away in the comments below!
Positive affirmation for the day: My inner environment remains calm and peaceful despite what’s going on in my external environment.
join the tribe
Join the green mo revolution! Subscribe to get Jess's updates & Green Mo Revolution e-book FREE with over 80 green smoothie recipes!
Write a Reply
This is a great article Jess, I have just been researching the same topic and was about to write an article on it but you have saved me the trouble.
Many people unknowingly consume synthetic vitamins and think they are benefiting from them when in fact they are just wasting their money. I did it for years!
Thanks,
Mike.
Great article Jess I have done a fair bit of research on the topic and was reluctant to admit that even with my high plant based diet I needed to supplement. I live in a pretty remote town so our fresh produce is probably older than most city shops by the time it gets here! I started taking juice plus as it ticked all the boxes for me and I am now a franchisee spreading the word on whole foods and health. I love your site and pass on the link to all my customers too! Anyone interested to find out more my details can be found at http://www.energyfoodjuiceplus.com xxx
Hey Jess,
Interesting that you just posted info on this, when I was just watching a Gabriel Cousens video on the same topic!
It is a pity that in our world, even our best efforts can still leave us lacking in a particular area, but hey its our job to clean up the mess from generations gone by, so whatever it takes to thrive, I’m in!
My biggest uncertainty here is that not all naturopaths/integrative doctors are enlightened to 100% natural living so perhaps the advice I get (expensive advice usually) may not really be close to what I am after. Often in these cases it is best to take recommendations from others you know, so I might have to hunt around for someone local (i’m thinking Sandeep Gupta?)
I’m a strong believer in the sense that we, as humans, largely create our health by the level of awareness and self-love, however there is a scientist deep down inside me which understands that mechanics is mechanics, and sometimes you just need a particular input for the machine to work.
I look forward to seeing what supplements they suggest for me to take!
Keep up the good work, James
I am going to pin this – everyone needs to read this! I only take the supplements that my GP said I needed to take – Vitamin D & my beautician suggested – Evening Primrose Oil. Both have done exactly what I am taking them for. Seeing a Naturopath is on my to do list. I don’t think self diagnosing what supplements you take is a good idea for anyone.
Great post! I totally didn’t think of this! Will be checking the labels on my supliments tonight.
Aloha Jess. Awhile ago I bought supplements from a vendor that was listed on a reputable website. Then I read a post by Dr. Mercola about the dangers of magnesium stearate, and realized that ingredient was in most of the supplements I had bought!
That’s why posts like this one are so important so we can be educated consumers, realizing that when all is said and done, it’s ourselves that we need to trust.
I wish you’d touched on ‘organic’ minerals (ie. the ones that contain a carbon atom vs the ones that are naturally sourced!) It’s a huge point of confusion for many people.
What are your favourite brands? I use a few Lifestream, like the yeast-based selenium and the Acerola C. Jury is still out on Natural Coral Calcium as it’s still a carbonate form.
I find that herbal supplements and whole food supplements (eg coconut oil, cacao, chia seeds etc) provide just about every natural nutrient available and are far more accessible to the body than traditional vitamin and mineral supplements.
Thanks Jess, an informative article. I buy my supplements from a herbalist. I will check the ingredients out though, just in case. Have a great week. xxoo
This is interesting but I must admit I am still confused about my vitamins. Is there any downside to all natural (I know how silly that sounds but do they add some to make the vitamins more stable or last longer etc etc?) Either way this is a great article and really got me thinking. Thank you, lovely! xo
Anyone have a any thoughts on methylcobalamine? I’d appreciate it. Thank you!
Alexandra » Yep, that’s the correct form of B12 x
Hi Jess. I was just wondering if you recommended any supplements that anyone should take in general, I don’t eat animal products, and I wanted to know if you’d recommend B-12 or any other supplements? Do you think things like iodine, probiotics and multivitamins are necessary for everyone? Thanks,
Lauren xx
Lauren » Hi Lauren, yep I definitely recommend B12 if you’re a vego. Just look for the methylcobalamine type. Yes, iodine, probiotics and a good multi are generally needed by most people these days. They are great all-rounders. xx
I take a variety of supplements daily, and have noticed an improvement in my energy levels and anxiety issues. I pick the supplements up from my local health store, which I presumed was reliable, but it looks like it may not be! Thanks for the heads up, looks like I’ll be heading back to my naturopath!
Hi Jess, could you please tell me what multi you take? Thanks, keep up your amazing work!
Helen » Hi Helen, I don’t take a multi seeing as I take almost everything else under the sun ha ha. However when I did I took the Metagenics brand. x
Thanks Jess, this is really helpful!
Thanks for yet another super important informative post Jess, love you blog!
Hello.
this is very interesting. I have been takeing a multi for a long time now. I was told it was the bees knees of multis. Now… I read the ingredients and it has ALL the baddies! I’m shocked. And bummed. Thank you for letting us know
Hello, I’ve. Been taking vitamin c powder form absorbic acid from Soloray brand I read on Chris beat cancer site. What is wrong with this form and which form is best to take? I’ve been taking high amounts
Love this post Jess. So many people are under the false assumption that if it’s sold in a Health Food store or your G.P
Ooopps, Love this post Jess. So many people are under the false assumption that if it’s sold in a Health Food store or your G.P or Naturopath suggested it…then it must be healthy! I have done a lot of research on this topic in the past for my own health. Lucky for me my husband is a Chiropractor, Doctor of Natural Medicine & Kinesiologist who uses muscle testing to ask the body what it needs/does not need. This makes it so much easier to navigate what the individual body deems harmful by using it’s innate wisdom. Thanks for shining the light on such an important topic Jess.
Agghhh, I’m so annoyed, I’ve been taking a multivitamin for the past 3 months and I’ve just checked and each and every synthetic you mentioned above is listed in their ingredients!! What a waste of time that was
My mission this month is to find a synthetic free one. Thanks so much for sharing.
This is brilliant! I am printing this out to have this n my kitchen. I’ve heard a lot of information about having natural vitamins before and I’ve been trying to buy them as such. But now I have a guide that I can use while shopping for supplements. Who we trust now when shopping? It’s become so confusing to buy products because manufacturers are not really bound by any rules and they can put whatever they want on a label. A very helpful post!
Thanks for this post. I just looked at all my supplement labels and they are indeed synthetic. I had no idea.
Hello – Love your site, Jess, and thank you for all your hard work and sharing your knowledge. I am an American and have been seeing a very reputable nutritionist here and she had suggested several supplements from two brands, Xyymogen and Thorne, which are expensive and considered very good by many. But I have checked several of them today and they have a few of these bad ingredients. This is so upsetting. Can anyone suggest a few brands to check out that generally do not contain these things. I am overwhelmed and do not know where to turn. Thanks!
Hi Jess,
I’ve been reading your blog for almost three years now and you are a constant inspiration for me! Thank you for your thoughtful post. However, I feel a bit alarmed with it, especially that my husband’s Gerson practitioner recomended some supplements including vegetable magnesium stereate. Are you sure this is toxic? If you carefully read the labels of Gerson therapy supplements such as pacreatin or niacin available in one fo the recommended pharmacies – they also do contain things like magnesium stereate or phospate. Any comments on this? I’m really curious!
xxx
Thanks you very much for this post Jess.
Using this as a checklist for the next supplement purchase! Thank you for the great info & buying guide!
Hi Jess, Can you recommend any brands of tablets/vitamins that you find do not contain synthetic ingredients?
Thanks
Hi Jess, thanks for great post -I was diagnosed with a condition called Pyrroles a couple of months ago and it requires a lifetime of zinc, B6 & many other vits & minerals to be taken to balance.. I see a biomedical doctor and she recommended Thorne Research – however I found things like talc and some other nasties in their products.. The one I’ve found to be the most pure so far is Solgar.. It states the magnesium stearate as vegetable magnesium
stearate – so pretty sure it’s not synthetic!? But I would love any other thoughts on this product or any others people recommend too! Thanks heaps!
Hi Jess..Vitamin C is so important, we cannot O.D on it, and actually most don’t take nearly enough, I watched a Documentary called ” Food Matters” and one man decided to do an experiment where he got injected with 250,000 mg (yes that is right!) of Vitamin C to see what side effects it may have, the result was very little, I recommend people watch it. I have been using Micro Genics..but Ascorbic acid-from Calcuim Ascorbate Dihydrate is synthetic I pressume? Thanks so much for your advice on this subject!
I use Standard Process supplements which are ALL Whole Food supplements. They are made from a huge organic farm up in Wisconsin. You can get them from your local health care professional – lots of chiropractors carry them
.
Standard Process Issues Voluntary Recall of Three Supplements Because of Possible Health Risk
Contact:
Consumer:
Standard Process Inc.
866-397-3237
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE – June 29, 2012 – Standard Process Inc. of Palmyra, WI 53156 is voluntarily recalling the following three dietary supplements due to potential Salmonella contamination:
Cataplex ACP (Product number 0700 and 0750) Lot 114
Cataplex C (Product number 1650 1655) Lot 114,, @Standard Process Issues Voluntary Recall of Three Supplements Because of Possible Health Risk
Contact:
Consumer:
Standard Process Inc.
866-397-3237
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE – June 29, 2012 – Standard Process Inc. of Palmyra, WI 53156 is voluntarily recalling the following three dietary supplements due to potential Salmonella contamination:
Cataplex ACP (Product number 0700 and 0750) Lot 114
Cataplex C (Product number 1650 1655) Lot 114
Thanks Jess, eye opening. Just filled my trash can. Only had two worth saving in the cabinet.
Carly ;please check you don’t have the above named products.
Thanks for the Info Jess…Will be doing a major shake up I feel!
I don’t think magnesium stearate Is to be of concern
http://www.michaelmooney.net/magnesiumstearate.html
riboflavin is vitamin b2- why is that on the list?
Absorbic acid is a form of vitamin C
Chemical one is D-ascorbic acid, misprint maybe.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ascorbic_acid#section_4
Not sure about the others
Hey Jess!
Could you recommend a natural B complex? I have been using Thorne Research, but much to my dismay, it contains the Thiamine as HCL and Riboflavin, the only other brand I have found to be all natural is the Innate response formula. Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated fellow wellness warriors
Hi Jess.
Thanks for such a brilliant article. It just confirms for me that I am on the right track with my Neways products, which are chemical free, pharmacy grade so you know what you are taking will work.
I use the green qi powder in my green smoothies to give them a boost, just amazing for my immune system and energy levels for a mum of two under three. Check out http://www.monicag.myneways.com.au for amazing vitamins, and health and environment conscious products for our family, home and especially our kids skin! Recommend by leading naturopaths and homeopaths. The results really do speak for themselves, I wouldn’t use anything else for my family.
1. Don’t take supplements as they are still processed products even they come from natural sources. You will never know with what way they take those vitamins, minerals, etc out.
2. Natural vitamins and mineral exist as a compound, like an orange contains vitamin C, A, etc. and they are good for your health. But supplements are not a compound. For example, when you take vitamin D as a single supplement, the dose might be too high as vitamin D’s half life within body is 28 days – that means it’s hard to control the dosage and it might be too much and enough to hurt your health.
In short, eat only what God creates. That’s my experience.
Those supplements are a big industry. Remember so far no scientist can create an orange in lab.
So interesting! Thank you for the information! I can’t believe it! How can they get away with it. My naturopath recommended my supplements n now when I look at the information they are all synthetic! It seems to contradict the whole point of taking them!!! Thanks for opening my eyes!
hi jess i was once a supplement queen, i was taking just about everything lol, im big on wholefood raw nutrition , then someone put me onto juiceplus a wholefood nutrtition supplement, containing 17 fruits and vegetables and grains, didnt think much of it at first if i was to be honest, but at around 4.5 months after taking it, i started experience some amazing results, and my son who was constantly sick and was the reason i tried them in the first place has even better results than me, i eat a wholefood diet anyway rich in vegetables , i juice them, i eat them i do everything with them, but now i realise i was still not getting enough and my son definately wasn’t, i have my whole family on it now, and friends who are also seeing awesome results, especially energy and getting sick less often, check out the website http://www.juiceplus.com.au/+lc11280 for more info xxxx
Jess would it be possible to know what brand of multi vitamin you use? I’ve researched for months and can’t seem to find a good product that fulfills all these high standards. Plus, I’d like it to be from organic foods and have no vitamin A as I already take cod liver oil. It would save me so much time if you’d let me know what you take.. I’m certain you’ve discovered the best. Thank you!
Thank you for this article. Jess, where did you inject the B12? In your arm, outer thigh, or bum. I am going to inject it, Gerson says in your bum but doing it yourself is a bit harder to reach, just wondering how you went.
Thank you!!
Hi James, I have been seeing Dr Gupta for the last 18 months and would highly recommend him. He is all about the very best supplements and suggests Biotrace as the supplier as they resource the very best and purest ingredients. He is extremely kind, genuine and very concerned about your health. My health continues to improve under his care – I think he is awesome!!
Metagenics is such a great brand for supplements! Highly recommend
)