Juicing versus blending
This is a question I get asked all the time. What is better: juicing or blending? To which I always say; why does it have to be one or the other? Juices and smoothies both serve two different, yet equally important, roles in our wellness regime.
Being a product of the Gerson Therapy, I am fiercely loyal to my juicer. Having drunk 13 juices each day for the past 17 months, and between six and 11 for the two years prior to that, the thing has practically saved my life. While there hasn’t really been any room in my diet to drink smoothies as well, when my juicing schedule slows down a bit, I will definitely be introducing some daily blended greens.
What’s the difference?
When we juice our veggies, we are removing the indigestible fibre and making the nutrients more readily available to the body in much larger quantities than if you were to eat the fruits and vegetables whole. When you drink fresh veggie juices, your body is soaked in nutrients, without having to use up any of its precious energy. It’s like injecting goodness straight into your blood stream. Sitting down to eat five large carrots and one large apple would take a heck of a lot longer to do than if you were to juice those suckers. I can’t imagine it would be as fun or tasty either.
Unlike juices, smoothies still contain all of the fibre from the vegetables – however, the blending process breaks the fibre apart and makes it easier to digest. They are more filling and generally faster to make than juice, so they can be great to drink first thing in the morning as your breakfast, or for snacks throughout the day.
Juicing and blending rules!
• It’s best not to combine fruits and vegetables (unless it’s apple). This messes with your digestive enzymes. This doesn’t seem to matter too much in green juices and smoothies, but vegetables like carrots, beetroots, broccoli and zucchini don’t combine well with fruit due to their high starch content. In his book Food Combining Made Easy, Dr. Herbert Shelton explains that starchy foods have to be eaten alone because starches are digested with enzymes different from those used for any other food group. Combining starchy foods with fruit may cause fermentation and gas. However, Dr. Shelton found that green leafy veggies combine well with pretty much everything.
• Try to drink your juice or smoothie straight away. After 15 minutes, light and air will destroy much of the nutrients. If you can’t drink it straight away, transfer to a dark airtight container until you’re ready.
• Clean your equipment after each use. Otherwise, pulp will get caught in the machine and oxidize making your next juice all gross.
The right equipment
To get the most benefit out of your juices and smoothies, it’s important to use the right equipment. Invest in a good-quality juicer. Cheaper, centrifugal juicers introduce heat and oxygen and destroy the much-needed nutrients in your fruits and vegetables. They are also generally rubbish at juicing greens. While it may cost you a bit more initially, a premium cold-press juicer will produce a superior-quality juice and allow you to extract more from your fruit and vegetables, saving expense in the long-term. The machines themselves will also generally last longer. In contrast to the rough extraction of centrifugal juicers, mastication or cold-press juicers compress fruit and vegetables to ‘squeeze’ out their juice.
The same goes for a blender. You want a blender that is gentle on your produce and doesn’t heat up the enzymes as it’s pulling apart the fibres. We spend money on gadgets, clothes, restaurants and other luxuries so, if you can afford it, investing in your health by buying a quality juicer or blender is totally worth it.
My top three juicers: The Angel, The Champion, The Norwalk (the best by far, but very expensive)
My top three blenders: VitaMix, Vitacrush, Tribest Personal Blender
Do you prefer juicing or blending? Why? What’s your favourite drink recipe?
Positive affirmation for the day: I am kind and compassionate to everyone I meet today.
join the tribe
Join the green mo revolution! Subscribe to get Jess's updates & Green Mo Revolution e-book FREE with over 80 green smoothie recipes!
Write a Reply
I like Green juice so much better than smoothies but since I can’t store it, I tend to do smoothies. I do a ton of Carrot Combinations in the Norwalk, and then store in the fridge for a few days. Smoothies for the average person are more affordable & you can do in a good blender, if you don’t have the Vita-Mix. So it seems like, especially here in the States where people SWEAR they have ZERO time to eat anything in the morning that resembles food, to be easier to do smoothies than juice. I prefer juice!!! But I do notice the price difference, for sure!! You are the Juicing Queen already!!
You need a “crown”! Princess Jess the Juicer.
Or “Juicy Jess”?? You might get too many hits looking for something else if you were “Juicy Jess”
hi Jess! love this post because i’m looking to go out and buy my first juicer and upgrade my old stock-standard blender to make new yummy juices and smoothies
also thank you for pointing out not to mix fruit with vegies, i didn’t know that before so i’ll keep them separated from now on. on that note, how do you make vegies taste better without the fruit? i don’t mind the taste of vegies, in fact i love vegies but for me personally i think they’re easier to drink if sweetened with fruit.
love your work, every morning i look forward to your daily posts!
xoxo
Thank you! The best way is to just add an apple – apples can be added to any juice recipe. I have just added this paragraph to the post to clear up that point a little better:
“This doesn’t seem to matter too much in green juices and smoothies, but vegetables like carrots, beetroots, broccoli and zucchini don’t combine well with fruit due to their high starch content. In his book Food Combining Made Easy, Dr. Herbert Shelton explains that starchy foods have to be eaten alone because starches are digested with enzymes different from those used for any other food group. Combining starchy foods with fruit may cause fermentation and gas. However, Dr. Shelton found that green leafy veggies combine well with pretty much everything.”
xx
Hi Jess, great post! I am writing to ask if you could please provide more information about this sentence: “It’s best not to combine fruits and vegetables (unless it’s apple). This messes with your digestive enzymes”? I have never heard/read that before and I would like to look into it as I am currently having 4 green smoothies per day which are a mix of green vegetables with lemon and lime, and occasionally other fruits. Any additional information or references you could provide on this point would be very gratefully received. Thanks for your wonderful blog. I always learn something new and interesting in your posts.
Thanks Ginger! I have just added this paragraph to clear up that point a bit more:
“This doesn’t seem to matter too much in green juices and smoothies, but vegetables like carrots, beetroots, broccoli and zucchini don’t combine well with fruit due to their high starch content. In his book Food Combining Made Easy, Dr. Herbert Shelton explains that starchy foods have to be eaten alone because starches are digested with enzymes different from those used for any other food group. Combining starchy foods with fruit may cause fermentation and gas. However, Dr. Shelton found that green leafy veggies combine well with pretty much everything.”
Hope this helps!
Jess x
Thanks so much Jess for taking the time to clarify this. I really appreciate it
)
My practioner has suggested the coway juicepresso as being quite good also
(looking at getting a second juicer as I’m paranoid about my angel falling from grace haha)
Does anyone have a cowy juicepresso and can recommend or compare to say the angel?
Thanks Jess, great article and very timely given my brand spanking new Norwalk arrived yesterday! and what a gorgeous piece of equipment it is! My children are now attributing your blog and Gerson Therapy to ‘ruining their childhood’ lol as my son puts it ie. with multiple daily juices, organic produce and a very noticeable change in all toxic related practise in the family home.
Undertaking my maiden juice on the beast of the Norwalk last night proved beyond a doubt the juice from this amazing machine by far exceeds that from a centrifugal style juicer. But hey, we all have to start somehwere right? My mother can’t afford the Norwalk and so she juices on the centrifugal. This is a better option that not juicing at all.
For those doubting the level of investment needed to buy a cold press type of juicer, this is my experience and humble view. I had been juicing with a standard centrifugal type juicer for some time and figured in time, as I grew into the concept of juicing I would scale up, if at all. I think there comes a time in everyone’s path to wellness where we experience a pronounced shift and start placing far more value and priority on choices that whilst significantly more expensive upfront, in the long term provide otherwise significantly improved health and wellbeing benefits. Not everyone reaches this point in the journey and that is for each of us to decide. Some are also limited by financial resources and that again is for each of us to manage.
I like to benchmark these otherwise untangibles benefits through the absence of disease, limited incidence of minor illness, increased energy levels, improved general health and overall wellbeing, not to mention sustainability of this beautiful and strained planet of ours.
In fending off sharp criticism from my young and naive children on the benefits of all this organic ‘stuff’ and juicing, I tell them it’s quite simple really – we either pay now or we pay later.
Hey Jess,
Hey maybe I’m a bit psychic? You totally answered my question from your last post.
I have a small follow up question. Which do you think is better: organic pink lady or non organic granny smith for purposes of juicing? I can’t find any organic granny smiths anywhere where I live. I say pink lady because that one seems to be the most sour organic apple on tge market right now.
Your thoughts?
John
Hi John, I reckon you are!
Absolutely organic pink lady apples. If you can’t get organic Granny Smiths, your best bet is to use tarty red apples. I faced this same dilemma earlier this year. Non-organic Granny Smiths have been so heavily sprays, have been in cold storage and are pretty much void of nutrients.
Hope this helps!
haha we are all born with intuition, our intuition is our gut feelings, our soul truth that will keep surfacing time and time again until we learn to listen and trust what we feel.
Hi Jess
I’m looking into Norwalk juicers – did you buy yours from the US or are they distributed in Australia (I’m from Victoria). Unfortunately I’m finding it hard to source a place here in Oz.
Thanks in advance
Sharon
Hi Sharon,
Yes we bought ours from the US and had it shipped here. You can only buy them from Norwalk. It makes it even more expensive with shipping and customs, but we still believe it’s worth it!
HI Jess,
I’ve ordered the norwalk from the US as well (*happy face) . I would like to ask you how much did the customs taxed on the norwalk and are you doing alright with the 4 cloths and bags or do you have to order more ?
Hi Jess,
Love the website. It looks fantastic and has really inspired me to get healthier! I have enjoyed fresh juices for years but have only recently started experimenting with smoothies. I usually do a combination of celery, spinach or silverbeet, kiwifruit, banana, lemon and spirulina. I have been making the smoothies for about 2 weeks but tend to feel a little nautious (don’t know if I’ve spelt that right – sicky) for a while after a green smoothie. Any feedback on this would be welcome.
Thanks Jess.
Ingrid
Nauseous! Sorry about that appalling spelling!
Does it take a lot of time to clean the Norwalk Juicer? For some reason I think by the time you are done juicing and cleaning another hour would have already passed and you would need to start to juice/clean all over again…
David » i David,
No it doesn’t take very long at all. Because all the parts are stainless steel, they clean up pretty quickly. It only takes about a minute to pull it apart and rinse each part. Once you get the hang of it, you get pretty speedy.
Mmmm I agree that there is an important space for juice and smoothies. I love them both.
Hi Jess,
I’ve notched you don’t have ginger in any of your recipes? Is there any reason for this? It seems to be popular else where
Chloe » Hi Chloe, we aren’t allowed ginger while on Gerson Therapy as it’s too stimulating for cancer patients. For other people it is great though!
Ginger is not good for people who have cancer? Why?
Valerie » Ginger is not allowed on Gerson Therapy because it has a stimulating effect I think. It is very good otherwise though!
Hi Jess,
Your blog has inspired me to start juicing, but at this stage we can’t afford the real, high quality juicers and it seems buying a cheaper centrifugal one has no real benefit or does it? A close friend has a Thermomix she said I’m welcome to use anytime and I was wondering if the Thermomix is good for making smoothies without introducing heat and oxygen and destroying the nutrients? I thought this might be a good option to start with! Thanks for your help!
hi jess! Just wanting to clarify something, I see that you’ve crossed off the angel juicer from your recommendation list. Is there a reason for this? I respect your opinion above all others and I’m looking to buy a good quality juicer but can’t quite afford the norwalk, do you still believe in the angel juicer? Or would I be better off with the champion? Thankyou kindly! Sending love and light you way!
Louise » Ooh no absolutely no reason. I didn’t cross it out, it must just be a broken link. Will fix it now. The Angel juicer is awesome! It’s my pick of the masticating juicers – definitely better than a Champion. xx
Hi Jess,
What about the thermomix? I have one which I love but is this any good for juices?
Cheers sam
Sam » Hi Sam, juice needs to have all of the fibre removed so this is why I recommend using a juicer. A Thermomix is great for blending though. x
Thank you for your article. I have been juicing for some time now, but I’m trying some of my recipes in a blender. I really like the blender (smoothies) for lunch when I can do them. It is fast and easy as you mention. Smoothies are more filling too. Thanks and Happy Holidays!
I used to absolutely love green juices but my Greenpower Hippocrates Juicer (she is a princess!) takes so long to make the juice and to clean because every setting has to be changed when making vegetables or fruits or wheatgrass and I was finding the whole process so time consuming. As a full-time law student it just wasn’t happening. That’s not to say I don’t love my juicer – it is a great piece of equipment. I’m just gonna invest in something slightly cheaper and easier to clean but still great quality like the Oscar Hurom Pro.
So since then I have been a die-hard smoothie-goer thanks to our awesome Vitamix that my mum and I bought together. Yep…I even converted her! I find smoothies a lot quicker, you can put more things in them (thinking superfoods etc…) and also easier to clean.
But I agree with Jess, both smoothies and juices have their place in this world. A combination of both is ideal.
Anyone looking to buy a juicer? I can sell you my Hippocrates Greenpower (its less than 2 years old and is in really good condition) for 1/2 the price of RRP.
Great article Jess!!
